On 2nd September 2013, Vodafone Group Plc. announced that it was disposing of its 45% interest in Verizon Wireless to Verizon Communications Inc.
At the same time, it also announced its intention to carry out a “Return of Value” to its shareholders, of which there are almost 400,000 in Ireland. Many of these shareholders had acquired Vodafone shares in exchange for their Eircom shares in 2001. The “Return of Value” would be partly in cash and partly in Verizon consideration shares.
On 14th May 2014 the Irish Revenue Authorities issued a comprehensive Tax Briefing outlining the tax treatment of the Vodafone Return of Value to its shareholders which provides comprehensive guidance on the calculation of the base cost for Capital Gains Tax purposes.
In what form will Vodafone return this value to the shareholders?
Either by the issue of:
What does that mean to the shareholder?
What does the Shareholder actually get?
What about the shareholders who exchanged their Eircom shares for Vodafone Shares in 2001?
These shareholders will NOT have a Capital Gains Tax liability.
Instead they will have a capital loss to offset against other chargeable gains arising in the current tax year or if unused they can be carried forward against future capital gains.
No Capital Gains Tax charge will arise for these shareholders in the following situations:
What is the base cost of the Vodafone Ordinary Shares?
The base cost for those Vodafone shares acquired in exchange for Eircom shares in 2001 is €4.46 per share.
Where in legislation are the apportioning rules?
Section 584(6) Taxes Consolidated Acts 1997 outlines the rule for calculating the apportionment of the original holding between the three elements of the new holding i.e. the cash element, the new Vodafone ordinary shares and the Verizon shares.
What about future disposals of these shares?
What is the Income Tax treatment for those opting for C Shares?
Individuals who opted for the C Shares have received a dividend from Vodafone which consisted of two elements:
The shareholder should include both amounts in his/her Income Tax Return i.e. the cash actually received and the market value of the Verizon Consideration Share Entitlement received. He/she must then pay the Income Tax arising on this dividend.
How is the tax on these dividends paid?
Are there any exemptions?
Individuals aged 65 years and over are entitled to claim an exemption from Income Tax if their total income i.e. income combined from all sources including Vodafone and Verizon dividends is
Will there be Dividend Withholding Tax on the Verizon Shares?
Dividends paid to shareholders of Verizon shares will, in general, be subject to US withholding tax, currently 30% of the gross dividend amount.
Irish resident shareholders can make a claim to the US Tax Authorities to be entitled to dividend withholding tax at the reduced rate of 15%.
This claim can be made by completing a Form W-8BEN Certificate of Foreign Status of Beneficial Owner for United States Tax Withholding and forwarding it to Computershare as stated on the form.
The Irish resident shareholder will be entitled to a credit for tax withheld against Income tax or Corporation tax on the dividends received.
The credit will be the lower of:
Please be aware that the information contained in this article is of a general nature. It is not intended to address specific circumstances in relation to any individual or entity. All reasonable efforts have been made by Accounts Advice Centre to provide accurate and up-to-date information, however, there can be no guarantee that such information is accurate on the date it is received or that it will continue to remain so.. This information should not be acted upon without full and comprehensive, specialist professional tax advice.
Over the years I’ve been asked many times how court settlements should be taxed. I’m still surprised by the number of people who are under the impression that a special tax for compensation and damages exists – it doesn’t.
In order to determine the correct tax treatment of damages and compensation it is essential to establish what the payment relates to.
There are several possibilities, the main ones being:
1. Personal Injury Compensation
A total exemption from Income Tax and Capital Gains Tax may be available in the case of personal injury compensation payments and income arising from investments of such compensation payments provided the following conditions, as outlined in Revenue’s IT 13, are satisfied:
2. Compensation for Revenue Loss
If the compensation is for loss of earnings then the payment will be liable to Income Tax in the case of individuals and partnerships and Corporation Tax for companies.
Examples of compensation liable to Income Tax are as follows:
3. Compensation for Capital Losses
The main examples under this heading are as follows:
These capital sums will be liable to Capital Gains Tax and treated as if there was a disposal of the asset.
INTERESTING STORY
I recently came across this situation:
Recently I’ve received a number of queries relating to the Irish tax treatment of CFDs or Contracts for Difference. Although the information available is plentiful and appears to be straight forward, it’s important to be aware that each situation is different and as a result the tax treatment may vary considerably.
Firstly, what is a Contract for Difference?
Essentially it’s a contract between two parties i.e. the investor and the CFD Provider. At the close of the contract, the parties exchange the difference between the opening and closing prices of a specified financial instrument, including individual equities, currencies, commodities, market indices, market sectors, etc. In other words, two parties take opposing positions on the difference between the opening and closing value of a contract i.e. the price will rise versus the price will fall.
Contracts for Difference offer wide access to different financial instruments from a single account for a fraction of the cost of buying shares. They do not carry voting rights like ordinary stock and CFD trades on certain Irish stocks are not liable to Stamp Duty.
CFDs can be traded ‘long’ or ‘short’ to speculate on rising or falling markets i.e. the investor speculates that an asset price will rise by buying (long position) or fall by selling (short position).
CFDs do not confer ownership of the investment. Instead the investor has access to the price performance which includes any dividend or corporate action equivalent.
What is the Irish tax treatment for profits / gains?
Contracts for Difference are treated as Capital Assets liable to Capital Gains Tax UNLESS they are deemed to be held in the course of a financial trade in which case the profits are liable to Income Tax under Case I, Schedule D.
According to Revenue eBrief No. 36/2007:
“The contracts require two parties to take opposing positions on the future value of a particular asset or index. Investments are often made on a margin of 20% of the contract amount. As well as the difference in value of the asset from beginning to end of the contract period, certain other notional income flows are taken into account in calculating the overall gain or loss.
Where the contract is long (expectation of a rise in price), notional interest is a deduction and notional income a credit in the calculation.
Where the contract is short (expectation of a fall in price), notional interest is a credit and notional income a deduction.
The chargeable gain will be calculated on the gain or loss resulting from the computations above and including a deduction for all necessary broker fees incurred in the full contract.
Actual interest paid, if any, on the margin amount put up will be chargeable under Case III in the ordinary way and does not come into the CGT calculation.”
What’s the difference between holding Capital Assets and operating a financial trade?
The concept of a “trade” is a matter of interpretation and is usually determined by a number of factors known as “badges of trade.”
For example, a once off transaction would not normally be considered a “trade.” Depending on the circumstances and the timing it may be liable to Capital Gains Tax or indeed may be exempt from tax. If, on the other hand, the investor was involved in a large number of transactions throughout the year of assessment then this activity would be most likely be considered to be a trade and therefore liable to Income Tax.
What are the “Badges of Trade”?
There are a number of factors which will determine the existence of a “trade”. There is, however, no decisive test and no legislative definition. There is considerable case law concerning this issue and in 1954 a Royal Commission was set up in the United Kingdom to consider what factors should be taken into account in deciding whether a trade exists. A report was published outlining the “Badges of Trade” which are as follows:
1. THE SUBJECT MATTER OF THE SALE.
While almost any form of property can be acquired to be dealt in, those forms of property, such as commodities or manufactured articles, which are normally the subject of trading, are only very exceptionally, the subjects of investment.
Again, property, which does not yield to its owner an income, or personal enjoyment merely by virtue of its ownership is more likely to have been acquired with the object of a deal than property that does
2. THE LENGTH OF PERIOD OF OWNERSHIP.
Generally speaking, property meant to be dealt in is realised within a short time after acquisition. But there are many exceptions from this as a universal rule;
3. THE FREQUENCY OF SIMILAR TRANSACTION.
If realisations of the same sort of property occur in succession over a period of years or there are several such realisations at about the same date a presumption arises that there has been dealing in respect of each;
4. SUPPLEMENTARY WORK.
If the property is worked on in any way during the ownership so as to bring it into a more marketable condition, or if any special exertions are made to find or attract purchasers, such as the opening of an office or large-scale advertising, there is some evidence of dealing. When there is an organised effort to obtain profit there is a source of taxable income. But if nothing at all is done, the suggestion tends the other way;
5. THE CIRCUMSTANCES THAT WERE RESPONSIBLE FOR THE REALISATION.
There may be some explanation, such as a sudden emergency or opportunity calling for ready money that negates the idea that any plan of dealing prompted the original purchase;
6. MOTIVE.
There are cases in which the purpose of the transaction and sale is clearly discernible. Motive is never irrelevant in any of these cases and can be inferred from surrounding circumstances in the absence of direct evidence of the seller’s intentions.
In Summary
Say an individual is employed in an investments role by day and makes considerable CFD profits in his/her spare time based on a significant number of transactions, how would this income be taxed?
Although opinions published by Revenue in the context of financial services are primarily concerned with group financing and treasury operations I believe they have direct relevance to this situation and should certainly be taken into consideration in ruling in favour of Income Tax Treatment.
In one such case, Revenue believed that the company was trading on the basis that the company was actively managing the business and making strategic decisions regarding financing and treasury operations. Despite the fact that the activities of the company were outsourced (i.e. no individuals were employed in the company), the outsourcing arrangement was managed and controlled by Irish resident directors with the appropriate level of specialized expertise in this area.
In this example, as the individual’s Irish PAYE employment relates to the area of financial services/investments, it would be difficult to see how Revenue could treat his/her C.F.D. activities as anything other than trading activities liable to Income Tax.
In summary, as the C.F.D. relates to a large number of transactions with a profit motive which requires a considerable amount of skill and expertise, it would be highly probable that this income would be liable to Income Tax and not Capital Gains Tax.
IN CONCLUSION
Please be aware that the information contained in this article is of a general nature. It is not intended to address specific circumstances in relation to any individual or entity. All reasonable efforts have been made by Accounts Advice Centre to provide accurate and up-to-date information, however, there can be no guarantee that such information is accurate on the date it is received or that it will continue to remain so.. This information should not be acted upon without full and comprehensive, specialist professional tax advice.
On 24th October 2013 the Finance (No. 2) Bill 2013 was published which confirmed the measures introduced by the Budget.
As the main priorities in Ireland at the moment are job creation and enterprise growth the following tax packages were introduced:
I. ENTERPRISE RELIEF– This is a new Capital Gains Tax relief which is aimed at entrepreneurs investing in assets used in new productive trading activities. The purpose is to encourage individuals to reinvest the sales proceeds from the sale/disposal of a previous asset into new productive trading or a new company. The main aspects of the relief are as follows:
(a) It applies to an individual
(b) who has paid Capital Gains Tax on the sale/disposal of an asset and
(c) invests in a new business
(d) at a cost of at least €10,000
(e) between 1st January 2014 and 31st December 2018.
(f) The investment cannot be disposed of earlier than three years after the investment date.
(g) Once the new investment is sold the Capital Gains Tax arising with be reduced by the lower of:
What type of assets are involved?
The assets must be chargeable business assets. Goodwill is included in this definition as are new ordinary shares in micro, small or medium sized enterprises after 1st January 2014. The main conditions are:
NOTE: Please be aware the commencement of this measure is subject to E.U. State Aid approval.
II START YOUR OWN BUSINESS – This is an exemption from Income Tax but not from Universal Social Charge and PRSI for a long term unemployed individual who is starting up a new, unincorporated business.
What is meant by long term unemployed?
It means some one who is continuously unemployed for the previous fifteen months.
What does this measure actually provide?
The first €40,000 of profits earned per annum will be exempt from Income Tax for two years.
III ENHANCEMENT OF EMPLOYMENT & INVESTMENT INCENTIVE – The main points of this new measure are:
IV STAMP DUTY – The transfer of shares listed on the ESM (Enterprise Securities Market) of the Irish Stock Exchange will be exempt from Stamp Duty. The ESM is the ISE’s market for growth companies.
The current stamp duty rate is 1%.
NOTE: Please be aware that this measure is subject to a commencement order.
V RESEARCH & DEVELOPMENT TAX CREDIT – The aim of this change is to assist smaller companies to access the tax credit without reference to the base year. The following changes have been made and will take place in the accounting periods starting on or after 1st January 2014:
VI VAT – There have been two major VAT changes:
PART II
The construction and building sectors saw the introduction of welcome changes:
I LIVING CITY INITIATIVE – The urban regeneration initiative has been extended to include residential properties constructed up to and including 1914 and covers the cities of Cork, Dublin, Galway and Kilkenny.
The aim is to stimulate regeneration of retail and commercial districts as well as to encourage families to return to historic buildings in Irish city centres.
II HOME RENOVATION INCENTIVE – This is a new incentive for home owners who:
What kind of relief is available?
Relief is available in the form of an Income Tax Credit of 13½% on qualifying expenditure between €5,000 (minimum) and €30,000 (maximum).
What does “Qualifying Work” mean?
Building extensions, window fittings, plumbing and tiling, plastering, etc. carried out by tax compliant builders.
How does the relief work?
Note: It is essential to keep in mind that the Revenue on-line system will track information on contractors involved and work carried out.
PART III
There were a number of other budget changes which will have a huge impact on our economy:
One Parent Family Tax Credit
Medical Insurance Tax Relief
Top Slicing Relief
Top Slicing Relief has been abolished completely for all ex-gratia lump sums paid on or after 1st January 2014.
D.I.R.T. (Deposit Interest Retention Tax)
COMPANY TAX RESIDENCE
There were changes to the company tax residence rules.
The company will be regarded as Irish resident for tax purposes where an Irish incorporated company is managed and controlled in another E.U. member state or treaty state and is not regarded as tax resident in any territory.
This applies from 24th October 2013 for companies incorporated after that date or 1st January 2015 for companies incorporated before 24th October 2013.
Rental income is calculated on the gross amount of rents receivable. A profit or a loss is calculated separately for each rental source. The rental income which is liable to Income Tax is the aggregate of the profits as reduced by the aggregate of the losses.
When completing an Income Tax Return, rental income from property situated in the Republic of Ireland is chargeable to tax under the provisions of Case V Schedule D while rental income from property situated outside the State is chargeable to tax under the provisions of Case III Schedule D.
It is important to remember that losses from one source cannot be written off against profits from the other. In particular, Irish rental losses cannot be written off against profits from foreign rental properties and vice versa.
The types of rental income liable to Income Tax can be more diverse than you might imagine. The following income is considered to be rental income, taxable under Case V, Schedule D:
For rental expenses to be deductible there are three main rules:
Specific Expenses include:
Please be aware you can never claim a deduction for your own labour. If you carry out repairs or gardening yourself, you cannot include this as a deductible expense against rental income.
The NPPR and Household charges are not allowable expenses against rental income.
Mortgage Interest
Broadly speaking, interest on money borrowed to purchase, improve or repair a rental property is deductible in calculating your rental income for tax purposes, subject to certain conditions.
The allowable deduction for interest accruing on loans used to purchase, improve or repair rented residential property is restricted to 75% of the total interest accruing.
This 75% restriction does not apply to non-residential property. In the case of offices, warehouses, etc. 100% of the interest is allowable against rents receivable.
A further restriction was introduced in 2006. Unless the landlord has complied with the registration and payment requirements of the PRTB (Private Residential Tenancies Board) in relation to each and all tenancies in the rented property then the interest on monies borrowed for the purchase, improvement or repair or rented residential properties will not be an allowable deduction against rents receivable.
If the loan to purchase the rental property includes stamp duty, legal fees, auctioneers’ fees, etc. then the interest on the loan must be apportioned. Only the interest relating to the actual cost of purchase, repair or renovation of the property is allowable.
Interest incurred prior to the first letting is not allowable (pre-letting expense) neither is the interest incurred after the final letting (post letting expense). Interest incurred during a period in which the landlord occupies the property is not allowable.
Wear and tear allowances are available in respect of capital expenditure incurred on fixtures and fittings provided by the landlord for the rented residential property. This includes furniture, showers, kitchen appliances, etc.
The rate is 12½% over eight years.
If an individual rents out a room in his/her sole or main residence as residential accommodation and receives up to €10,000 per annum this amount will be exempt from Income Tax, PRSI and the Universal Social Charge providing conditions are met.
The €10,000 limit includes rent, utility bills, laundry, food, etc.
If the individual receives in excess of €10,000, the Rent-a-Room exemption will NOT apply and the entire rent receivable will be liable to income tax, PRSI and the Universal Social Charge
An individual cannot avail of rent-a-room relief in respect of payments for accommodation in the family home by a child of the landlord under any circumstances. There is no restriction where rent is paid by other family members, for example, nieces and nephews.
The relief does not affect an individual’s entitlement to mortgage interest relief i.e. Tax Relief at Source.
The relief does not affect the individual’s entitlement to Principal Private Residence Relief from capital gains tax on the sale or disposal of the property.
You can opt out of the relief for a year of assessment by making an election on or before the return filing date for the year of assessment concerned.
If your landlord resides outside theRepublicofIrelandand you pay rent directly to them or electronically transfer the money into their bank account either inIrelandor abroad, you must deduct income tax at the standard rate of tax (currently 20%) from the gross rents payable.
Failure to deduct tax may leave the tenant liable for the tax that should have been deducted.
At the end of the year you are obliged to complete a Form R185 showing the tax deducted from the gross rents which you should then give to your landlord. The landlord can then submit this form to the Revenue Commissioners and claim this amount as a credit.
If, on the other hand the non-resident landlord has an agent who is resident in the state, then there is no obligation for the tenant to deduct tax from the rent. Instead the tenant should pay the gross rent to the agent.
The agent is then liable to pay income tax on the rents received from the tenant in the capacity of Collection Agent for the landlord. The agent is then required to register as self employed and submit an annual tax return and account for the tax due.
In general, rental income from property located outsideIrelandis calculated on the full amount of rents receivable, irrespective of whether or not it has or will be remitted intoIreland.
Broadly speaking, the same deductions are available in calculating the taxable rental income as if the rents had been received inIreland.
Income tax on these rental profits is chargeable under Case III of Schedule D.
In the case of an individual who is not domiciled inIreland, the taxable rental income is computed on the full amount of the actual sums received in the State without any deductions or reliefs for expenditure incurred.
Rental losses from the letting of property outside the State cannot be offset against rental income from the letting of property in the State and vice versa. Such losses can only be offset against future rental income from property outside the State.
Your residency affects your tax treatment in Ireland.
As an Irish resident, ordinarily resident and Irish domiciled individual you will be taxed on your worldwide income wherever it arises.
You will be taxed on all Irish and foreign source income in full and where possible you will be entitled to a tax credit for any foreign tax paid on foreign source income.
You will be considered to be Irish resident if you are present in the state for:
a) 183 days during the tax year in question or
b) 280 days or more over a period of two consecutive tax years.
Notwithstanding b), if you are present in Ireland for 30 days or less in a tax year you will not be treated as resident for that year unless you elect to be resident.
If you are not tax resident in the year of arrival under the above rules, you may elect to be tax resident for the year of arrival.
If you have any queries relating to whether or not you should elect to become Irish resident, please contact us on 01 872 8561
You will be considered ordinarily resident if you have been resident in the state for the previous three consecutive years.
Regardless of whether or not you are actually resident in the state in the fourth year, you will be considered ordinarily resident for the fourth year.
If you leave Ireland, you will cease to be ordinarily resident when you have been non resident for three consecutive years. You will not be considered to be ordinarily resident from the fourth year.
Domicile is a general legal concept.
It is relevant to you in relation to how certain foreign source income will be taxed in Ireland.
Under Irish law, every person acquires a domicile of origin at birth. In most cases this is the father’s domicile, however, in situations where the parents are unmarried or the father has died prior to the individual’s birth, the domicile of the mother is taken.
Your domicile can change if you acquire a domicile of choice.
For more information, please contact us on 01 872 8561
As a non resident, but ordinarily resident and Irish domiciled individual you will be taxed on all Irish and foreign sourced income in full.
The following income is exempt:
a) Income from a trade or profession, all duties of which are exercised outside Ireland.
b) Income from an office or employment, all duties of which are performed outside the state.
c) Foreign income providing it does not exceed a threshold amount of €3,810 in a tax year.
As a non resident, non Irish domiciled but ordinarily resident individual, you will be taxed on all Irish source income in full and foreign source income to the extent that it has been remitted into Ireland.
Again, the following income is exempt:
a) Income from a trade or profession, all duties of which are exercised outside Ireland.
b) Income from an office or employment, all duties of which are performed outside the state.
c) Foreign income providing it does not exceed a threshold amount of €3,810 in a tax year.
As non resident, non domiciled and non ordinarily resident, you will be taxed on Irish source income in full and on foreign source income in respect of a trade, profession, employment or office where the duties are exercised in Ireland.
As an Irish resident and ordinarily resident but non Irish domiciled individual, you will be taxed on Irish source income in full and on remittances of foreign source income.
Should you have any queries in relation to residency, ordinary residency or domicile, we would be delighted to discuss them with you.
Please be aware that the information contained in this article is of a general nature. It is not intended to address specific circumstances in relation to any individual or entity. All reasonable efforts have been made by Accounts Advice Centre to provide accurate and up-to-date information, however, there can be no guarantee that such information is accurate on the date it is received or that it will continue to remain so. This information should not be acted upon without full and comprehensive, specialist professional tax advice.